Do you really want to be a robot?
Do we think it would be better to be feelingless or emotionless and like a robot? Or do we want to embrace that we are feeling beings and do something to make them work for us?
April 13, 2018 • Written by Matthew Green
Do we think it would be better to be feelingless or emotionless and like a robot? Or do we want to embrace that we are feeling beings and do something to make them work for us?
Are we all going to get AI envy?
Earlier this week I was forwarded an article about how it is impossible to imbue artificial, or machine, intelligence (AI) with emotions because emotions aren’t programmable. I reflected, rather ruefully, that AI in its current form has been developed to dovetail perfectly with the current overarching culture. What better than to have an automaton to do the work tirelessly. To carry out instructions without argument and the messiness of guilt, disgust, sadness, anger, depression and all of the other difficult feelings that cloud us “mere” mortals.
It occurred to me that in some business environments this is what is demanded of employees. No untidy, messy or difficult emotions, please. In fact, keep any loud and quiet positive ones in check too. We can’t have too much laughter in the workplace. Just work your 10-12-14 hour or more days. Remember to bow to the god of return on investment because, you know you are the most costly of all the costs in the businesses expense line. Although this sounds very cynical I don’t know of many businesses that truly see their employees as their most valuable asset. Otherwise why would the business get rid of that most valuable asset when the ROI looks a bit thin, then?
Like it or not, we are feeling beings
Are we going to get AI envy? Do we think it would be better to be feelingless or emotionless? Do we really want to be more like that robot? Do we think that our bosses would, perhaps, prefer the robot worker over us, one that does not cry, or moan, or argue? Forget being replaced by another person, could being replaced by a robot be the next threat, and not only for the manufacturing environment? As a species our rational intellect is highly valued but, like it or not, we are feeling beings. Like it or not, our feelings will win every time, especially when we try to deny, avoid, numb and control them. First we get physically sick, then burnout looms, and eventually if we haven’t developed some form of addiction, we might get some or other type of mental illness. And lets not forget those dread diseases…
Feelings are the way our body says: “Take note; something in your life needs attention!” Our toolbox, however, is woefully empty with ways to manage our difficult and unpleasant feelings. Traditional interventions like psychotherapy and counselling often focus on the content of what and why we feel the way we do. They entail extended time frames and resources, both of which are in short supply for the average worker bee.
5th Place uses a different approach with Shape of Emotion, which focuses on the structure of what we feel. It is content-free, gentle, safe, easy to learn and use and quickly clears the effects of difficult feelings allowing for a return to a centred and resourceful state. Much better than being a robot, Maschinenmensch.
Join the resistance! Engage with us about how you can regulate your difficult feelings.
Matthew Green
Reducing the Certainty Deficit in high-performing people and teams · Emotional fitness coach
Matthew works with athletes, performance teams, and anyone who wants to reduce the Certainty Deficit in their situation or context.
The Certainty Deficit is the space between what you can do and what your body will let you do when it counts. It is context-specific and situational. A person or athlete can have zero deficit in one situation and a significant one in another.
The body holds beliefs that keep the Certainty Deficit in place. These beliefs run deeper than self-talk and faster than any conscious strategy. When they shift, the ceiling shifts, and new possibilities arise.
Matthew is also an emotional fitness coach who supports individuals to live and lead from a place of inner clarity and stability. The work is somatic-first, practical, and grounded.
If you're seeing a pattern that current approaches haven't shifted, let's talk.
My origin story: Why elite athletes underperform when it counts
More articles from 5th Place
-
It’s the oats
July 23, 2026After weeks of challenge on many fronts it felt as if a threshold had been crossed. A smoother week with resolutions and relief.
Continue reading → about It’s the oats -
The soundtrack to our lives
July 16, 2026Leah knows what music she likes, so do we. Music is important to us and has a useful lesson to teach too.
Continue reading → about The soundtrack to our lives -
All is not fair
July 10, 2026The Boks are back and it’s great to be on the winning side but a wrong call by the ref can change that and the way we feel. All is not fair so managing our state is the real job to be done.
Continue reading → about All is not fair
You may also enjoy reading these
-
The Enhanced Games funded the demonstration of its own irrelevance
May 27, 2026Forty-two athletes on full pharmacology. One world record broken by seven hundredths of a second. The Certainty Deficit at the inaugural Enhanced Games.
Continue reading → about The Enhanced Games funded the demonstration of its own irrelevance -
The window Arsenal struggles to close
April 17, 2026Arsenal lost 4 matches in 3 weeks, each decided in the same 20-minute window. The Certainty Deficit explains why.
Continue reading → about The window Arsenal struggles to close -
Why the Quad God Choked at the Olympics and Won Worlds Five Weeks Later
April 2, 2026Ilia Malinin, the “Quad God”, scored 329 at Worlds and 156 at the Olympics. Five weeks apart. Same body. Same jumps. The Certainty Deficit explains why the Quad God delivered in one and collapsed in the other.
Continue reading → about Why the Quad God Choked at the Olympics and Won Worlds Five Weeks Later
